Hello!
As we head into the final months of the year, the New York City real estate market continues to be defined by a familiar challenge: limited inventory. While transaction activity has slowed in certain segments, prices continue to rise, particularly at the higher end of the market. The latest third-quarter reports reinforce what I've been seeing firsthand: the market isn't necessarily lacking buyers, it's lacking inventory that meets their expectations.
In Manhattan, sales increased 3.3% year-over-year in the third quarter, with the median sales price rising 8.7% to $1.25 million. However, signed contracts declined 11.4%, reflecting a more cautious buyer pool, particularly at the lower end of the market where affordability remains a challenge.
Inventory continues to be the biggest story. Active listings fell 11.2% year-over-year to fewer than 6,200 properties, the lowest third-quarter level in at least a decade. New listings declined an even more significant 26.3%. With fewer options available, buyers are increasingly selective, but well-priced properties continue to attract attention.
The luxury market remains a notable exception to the slowdown. While signed contracts declined across nearly every price bracket, activity at the very top remained strong, with contracts above $20 million doubling compared to last year. This divergence highlights the different dynamics at play between buyers who are sensitive to financing costs and those who are less affected by them.
Brooklyn is experiencing an even more pronounced inventory shortage. Active listings declined 22.3% year-over-year to just 2,722 properties, with inventory falling across every submarket. The shortage is particularly acute for houses, where available inventory dropped 31.6%.
Not surprisingly, this scarcity continues to support pricing. The median house price increased 9.1%, while the average price per square foot rose 11.2%. Although the number of closings declined slightly by 2.8%, total sales volume increased to nearly $4 billion.
Much like Manhattan, Brooklyn's luxury market is outperforming. Signed contracts above $3 million increased 30.6%, even as inventory in that price range declined 38.2%. Meanwhile, transaction activity below $2 million softened, suggesting that affordability is increasingly influencing buyer behavior.
The common thread across both boroughs is that supply remains constrained, but demand hasn't disappeared. Buyers are still willing to transact, particularly for properties that are well-located, thoughtfully presented, and appropriately priced. At the same time, they're not willing to overlook shortcomings simply because inventory is limited.
For sellers, the lack of competition presents an opportunity, but pricing strategy remains critical. For buyers, patience and preparation are equally important. With fewer properties coming to market, being ready to act when the right opportunity presents itself can make all the difference.
I expect these dynamics to continue through the end of the year, with limited inventory supporting prices while buyers remain discerning about where they see value.
As always, if you need any assistance buying, selling, or renting in New York or elsewhere, it would be my pleasure to help.
Regards,