Big news broke this month on the recent National Association of Realtors
Settlement. Sellers sued NAR in a large anti-trust lawsuit, claiming NAR fixes commissions and forces the seller to pay the buyers' agents. There is a lot of information (and disinformation) swirling out there, so it's important to know a few things.
First, New York City does not operate under NAR, we are a part of the Real Estate Board of New York. So for
now, it is business as usual in NYC.
Second, many headlines and news articles have claimed that this will now make the process less expensive for consumers and bring down the cost of housing in the United States. From my professional vantage, I do not see this to be the case. I actually think this could be very harmful for the consumer.
Pricing is dictated by the market, not by commission. The United States is experiencing record low inventory, made even worse by many homeowners choosing not to move and give up their historically low interest rates. Additionally, there are institutional investors buying up housing and adding it to their large rental portfolios. Overall, there is not enough supply for the current demand, pushing up home prices.
Third, by decoupling the commission, the buyer now has to consider if they are willing to pay for representation. If the seller does not pay the commission, the buyer will have to
come out of pocket in cash and they can no longer include it in the mortgage. This doesn't seem less expensive to me... Also, buyers will now be disincentivized from having representation in what is likely the largest purchase of their lives. You wouldn't go to court without an attorney, so why would you buy a house without an agent?
Sellers might think they are saving money, but they won't be saving money if their deal blows up, they have to find a new buyer, and continue to carry the cost of the house. The goal of the transaction is to close for the highest price in the shortest amount of time. A buyer's agent is invaluable in this process, vetting and educating their client, and getting the deal across the finish line.
While I disagree with the conclusion of the settlement (watch two of my TikToks on the matter
here and
here), I know this will change the process of buying and selling a home. Ryan shares a bit about this on SquawkBox
here.
For now, we are all along for the ride. I continue to recommend protecting one of your largest assets by working with a professional advisor through the process. As Ryan said: good advice is expensive, bad advice (or no advice) can cost a fortune.